@mnickels It sounds like you need a feature request to add a post deferment message telling the user that by deferring they have agreed the policy will automatically run at the time specified in the 1st deferment.

As for having a policy in Self Service and also triggering periodically, I'd say don't do that if you're going to use the deferral option . By deferring the periodically triggered policy you have told Jamf Pro you don't want to run it until the deferment expires. Running that policy via Self Service is essentially just a GUI driven way of doing jamf policy -trigger xxxx, so it shouldn't run.

Here is my question about Policy Deferrals. What if the user never views the policy? "Enter the number of days to defer the policy after the user first views the policy in the Duration field." Copied from release notes. Let say you have users that never follow instructions or launch Self Service for anything, thus policies are never viewed, much less run in a timely manner. I want it to nag the hell out of them and then run after a set amount of days, viewed or not. Patch Management Policies do a pretty good job of that.

@erichughes I'd argue that the Policy Deferral feature is only intended for policies that have an automatic trigger. By definition Self Service only policies are ones that you expect users to manually initiate, so a deferral option doesn't make sense in that case.

@mnickels Did you ever find a suitable workflow for a policy you want users to be able to run in Self Service but also implement a deferral limit?

We're trying to implement a deadline for remaining Catalina upgrades. I created a policy with a Defer limit of 1 day, but I'm stuck on scenarios like this, e.g.:
- User turns on his laptop at 10 am for a meeting
- He gets the deferral popup in meeting
- He selects 1 hour because he's busy
- Meeting ends at 10:20, he opens Self Service ready to run the policy because he has free time
- Self Service won't actually run the policy
- He must wait until the deferral expires at 11 am, with no on-screen timer reminding him how many minutes are left

We've had a second Self Service policy w/ no triggers or deferrals for months, but getting the last users to actually run it is time-consuming. I'd prefer not to have 2 policies for a singular purpose

EDIT:
Thought I'd share a solution to my above issue:
-Leave existing policy for users to upgrade Catalina in Self Service (Policy ID = 1234)
-Create new policy w/ 24 hour Deferral limit and 1 payload in Files & Processes containing the following command:

#!/bin/sh

currentuser=$( scutil <<< "show State:/Users/ConsoleUser" | awk '/Name  && ! /loginwindow/ { print $3 }' )

uid=$(id -u $currentuser)

/bin/launchctl asuser "$uid" sudo -u "$currentuser" /usr/bin/open "jamfselfservice://content?entity=policy&id=1234&action=execute"

-i.e. New policy simply triggers the original policy
-The new policy reminds the user, giving the choice to Start Now or Defer XX minutes. The user can still start from Self Service at any time
-New policy is lightweight and only requires managing the scope, frequency, and deferral limit, none of the "meat" of the original policy's scripts & parameters