Skip to main content
Question

Off Topic: MacBook Pro hard drives

  • September 20, 2011
  • 1 reply
  • 9 views

Forum|alt.badge.img+10

Hi all,

I've inherited a gang of MacBooks and Pros that have had the factory hard disks swapped out for Western Digital Scorpio Blue 500GB WD500BEVT.
This was done because the previous IT dept were all PC techs ;) and they took a cost effective PC approach without thought.
Since I've been here, most of these machine report to Console of disk I/O errors and a lot of ThrottleDisk I/O

I'm not a hardware engineer but the machines that have these drives installed usually come back to me with Kernel Panics, system freezes, hangs before login, I even see some that at reboot does the firmware update bar (but never find a firmware)… and the only common denominator I find is always griping about disk I/O.

So, I ask you guys/gals … does anyone swap out factory drives and any clues as far as what I should I be looking at for a replacement drive for Macs?
Our preferred vendor has no clue of Apple except they all tote iPhones… Actually, we have no Apple vendor… it's not my call, I told them but….. well, ya know how IT admins can be ;)

Thanks in advance,

--
Pat Camporeale
"You don't need to be a mechanic to drive a car."

1 reply

Forum|alt.badge.img+31
  • Honored Contributor
  • September 20, 2011

Last year was our last year for our 1:1 with the 2007 Macbooks. They
were 4 years old at that point and been used by teenagers, so they were
banged up. I saw so many HD failures it was ridiculous. We just
ordered mass amounts of HDs from CDW I believe and we purchased several
brands. A hard drive is a hard drive pretty much these days, so I would
go with the best deal you can get for the dollar.

-Tom