Yes. I just ran into this issue on 10.14 Macs. Even without a configuration profile, I try to uncheck the "Share Mac Analytics" but it always comes back checked, even after a reboot.

So, this seemed to stick. I am going through the Jamf CIS 10.13 GitHub scripts and found this command line:

defaults write /Library/Application Support/CrashReporter/DiagnosticMessagesHistory.plist AutoSubmit -int 0

Try opening Terminal and running that line. Here is the full script they are using if you are curious.

2.6.8 Disable sending diagnostic and usage data to Apple

Verify Organizational score

Audit2_6_8="$(defaults read "$plistlocation" OrgScore2_6_8)"

If organizational score is 1 or true, check status of client

If client fails, then remediate

if [ "$Audit2_6_8" = "1" ]; then AppleDiagn=$(defaults read /Library/Application Support/CrashReporter/DiagnosticMessagesHistory.plist AutoSubmit) if [ $AppleDiagn == 1 ]; then defaults write /Library/Application Support/CrashReporter/DiagnosticMessagesHistory.plist AutoSubmit -int 0 echo "$(date -u)" "2.6.8 remediated" | tee -a "$logFile"
fi
fi

I was told this is PI-002899 by Jamf Support @Euwanh

Yea thanks. I had to create a download the profile and then edit the line. 'AllowDiagnostic' to false.

@afarnsworth - I cant locate that in the known issues list known issues. Do you have further details ? thx

Not sure if I am blind but I have just tried to recreate this profile again and the option 'AllowDiagnostic' is not there. Has anyone else noticed this?